Author: Gopika Karunakaran a student at Government law college, Vellore.
Abstract:
The Mahadev Betting App Case is a serious legal situation that involves illegal internet gambling, money laundering, and possible links to organized crime. The software, run by Saurabh Chandrakar and Ravi Uppal, encouraged unlawful betting, making almost ₹200 crore daily. The Enforcement Directorate (ED) launched investigations in 2022, revealing a complicated network of money laundering via Benami accounts and hawala transactions. The lawsuit had an international dimension, linking the operators to crime syndicates, including connections to mobster Dawood Ibrahim. Furthermore, the political ramifications of the case, including claims of payments implicating Chhattisgarh’s Chief Minister, have added a contentious aspect. The legal proceedings have involved several courts, including the Supreme Court, the Delhi High Court, and the CBI.
IN THE HON’BLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Enforcement Directorate
The Mahadev Betting App Case has involved multiple courts and benches in legal proceedings, which are currently ongoing. Key benches involved in this case are:
- Supreme Court Bench Case:
Sunil Dammani versus Enforcement Directorate (2024).The Supreme Court heard arguments on whether to give bail to Sunil Dammani, who had been arrested by the Enforcement Directorate. The bail application was considered by a bench chaired by Justices A.S. Bopanna and M.M. Sundresh. The Supreme Court granted bail under terms such as regular appearances at the ED office and restrictions on international travel. Citation: Sunil Dammani v. Enforcement Directorate, Supreme Court of India (2024).
2. High Court Delhi:
The Delhi High Court was most likely involved in hearings related to the Enforcement Directorate’s investigations, particularly the money laundering aspect of the case under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), but specific details or judgments involving the bench are not yet publicly available.
3. Special CBI Court or Economic Offenses Court
Because the case concerns money laundering and unlawful gaming, subordinate courts such as the Special CBI Court or the Economic Offenses Wing (EOW) Court may hear particular PMLA and gambling crimes. The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), which took over the case from the EOW, is scheduled to have hearings in this regard, although no information about the specific bench handling this issue in the CBI court has been provided.
4. Other District Courts (e.g., Chattisgarh)
The Chhattisgarh courts are likely to have handled early phases of investigations, particularly those involving local businessmen or individuals detained in connection with the Mahadev Betting App.
Introduction:
The Mahadev Betting App Case has surfaced as a major controversy involving an online betting platform that allowed illegal gambling in a variety of sports, including cricket, football, and tennis. The app, run by Saurabh Chandrakar and Ravi Uppal from Chhattisgarh, is said to produce around ₹200 crore each day. The Enforcement Directorate (ED) has claimed that the app used a franchising model, transferring revenues to associates on a 70-30 split, and used a network of Benami bank accounts to launder money. Investigations have found international connections, including those with mobster Dawood Ibrahim’s brother, Mushtaqeem Ibrahim Kaskar, who is thought to have worked with the marketers to create a similar betting software for Pakistan.
The case has garnered political attention, with suspicions that Chhattisgarh Chief minister Bhupesh Baghel paid ₹508 crore in kickbacks from the app’s creators. The Chief Minister has disputed these charges, viewing them as an attempt to destroy his character. The ED has filed charges against 14 individuals, including Chandrakar and Uppal, and attached assets worth ₹41 crore. The probe also resulted in the arrest of actor Sahil Khan for alleged involvement in the scheme. This case demonstrates the intricacies of internet gambling operations, the difficulties in regulating such platforms, and the vast networks engaged in money laundering activities.
Fact of the case:
The Mahadev Betting App Case has surfaced as a major money laundering scam involving an online platform that allowed illegal gambling on a variety of games like as poker, card games, badminton, tennis, football, and cricket. The program was run by Saurabh Chandrakar, a Dubai resident, and his accomplice Ravi Uppal, who are both originally from Chhattisgarh. The Enforcement Directorate (ED) claims that the app operated by franchising “panel/branches” to known associates on a 70-30 profit split, utilizing the platform to recruit new users, generate IDs, and Money laundering is carried out using a complicated network of Benami bank accounts. The activity generated approximately ₹200 crore per day.
Historical background:
- Rise of Online Betting Platforms (2010s–2020s):
Online gambling and betting have grown in popularity over the last decade, because to the proliferation of cellphones, the internet, and a technologically literate population. Many of these platforms, including Mahadev, operated without formal licensing and frequently evaded investigation by operating under the radar and using encrypted apps. As a result, illegal betting services attracted a considerable user base, particularly in countries like India, where gambling laws are tough but enforcement is difficult. Platforms like Mahadev provided easy access to popular gambling games such as cricket betting, poker, and other card games, which aided their rise.
- Mahadev App Origins:
The Mahadev Online Book (or Mahadev Betting App) was founded by Sourabh Chandrakar and Ravi Uppal, two entrepreneurs from Chhattisgarh, India. They capitalized on India’s growing desire for online gambling by developing an easy-to-use platform for betting on sports and other games.- The enterprise initially targeted a certain population but swiftly grew to generate up to ₹200 crore each day in unlawful earnings.
- App’s Popularity and Scope:
As the app grew in popularity, it drew both casual and high-stakes gamblers. This caught the attention of law enforcement, but the operators remained ahead of the authorities by continually altering their operations, using encrypted apps, and keeping a low profile. The app also evolved into a more complicated operation, with numerous “fronts” for money laundering activities, including the use of hawala networks and connections to criminal syndicates, such as those linked to Dawood Ibrahim’s organization.
- Investigations and Arrests:
The illegal nature of the enterprise drew the attention of law enforcement officials. In early 2024, the Chhattisgarh Economic Offences Wing (EOW) filed a FIR against the operators, prompting the Enforcement Directorate (ED) to investigate money laundering and fraud related to the app. The arrest of important individuals like as Sourabh Chandrakar and Ravi Uppal, as well as the attachment of properties worth hundreds of crores, was a significant step toward revealing the scope of the operation.
- Global Connections and worldwide Impact:
The inquiry discovered worldwide links to hawala operations, including Dawood Ibrahim, one of India’s most sought criminals. The app’s association with criminal groups sparked concerns about the possibility of organized crime being linked to online gaming platforms. Interpol issued a red alert to assist in apprehending the suspects, with some of them located outside of India, mainly in Dubai. The operation thus had worldwide repercussions, demonstrating how online gambling rings may cross boundaries.
- Legal and Political Implications:
The case drew political attention due to the size of the business, prompting concerns about regulating online betting and gambling in India. Authorities are now focused on tougher enforcement of gaming legislation and increased oversight of such operations. The Mahadev Betting App case is part of a larger campaign to combat online gambling and money laundering in India, and it highlights the need for revised legislative frameworks to handle the changing nature of cybercrime in the digital era.
Issue of the case:
1. Illegal Online Gambling and Betting:
– Violation of Gambling Laws
– Unregulated Platforms
– Impact on Youth
2. Money Laundering and Financial Crimes:
– Money Laundering Networks
– Integration with Criminal Syndicates
3. Cybersecurity and Digital Crime:
– Technological Challenges in Enforcement
– Data Privacy Issues
4. International Jurisdiction and Extradition:
– Cross-Border Investigation
– Global Networks of Illegal Gambling
5. Economic and Social Impact:
– Impact on the Economy
– Financial Losses for Users
– Psychological and Social Harm
6. Lack of Effective Regulation for Online Platforms:
– Legal Gaps in the Framework
– Call for Reform
7. Public Perception and Trust:
– Erosion of Trust in Digital Platforms
– Reputation of the Online Gaming Industry
In summary, the Mahadev Betting App case touches on numerous complex issues ranging from illegal gambling, money laundering, cybersecurity, and international law, to the economic and social impact of unregulated online platforms. It highlights the urgent need for a cohesive approach to tackle such problems in the digital age.
Arguments:
Arguments of the Prosecution (Enforcement Directorate and Law Enforcement Agencies) :
- Money laundering and fraudulent activities:
The prosecution claims that the Mahadev Betting App is a front for money laundering, with unlawful gambling taking place on a large scale. The app allegedly produced ₹200 crore per day through unlawful gambling on sports and games.- The Enforcement Directorate alleges that the accused exploited the platform to launder money through a complex network of bank accounts and hawala operations, siphoning revenues abroad, mainly in Dubai and Pakistan.
- International Money Laundering Network:
The prosecution has underlined the case’s worldwide reach, demonstrating the app’s connections to countries such as the United Arab Emirates and Pakistan. Investigations revealed connections to mobster Dawood Ibrahim’s network, adding to the case’s international dimension. They claim that by using Benami accounts, the accused were able to dodge regulatory safeguards and funnel their unlawful funds overseas.
- Political Connections and Corruption:
A large portion of the prosecution’s case revolves around allegations of political corruption, including claims that Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel accepted payments from app promoters. This assertion, while contested by Baghel, adds a political component to the case, which the prosecution utilizes to establish the syndicate’s power.
- Financial Proceeds and Asset Attachments:
The prosecution claims that the illicit enterprise generated substantial financial gains, resulting in the attachment of assets worth thousands of crores. This is part of the endeavor to keep the accused from profiting from their illicit activity.
Arguments of the Defence (Accused and Their Legal Representatives):
- Denial of involvement in money laundering:
The defence claims that the accused, specifically Saurabh Chandrakar and Ravi Uppal, were not involved in any money laundering activities. They argue that the betting app’s operations were genuine, and that there is no clear proof linking the promoters to money laundering or illegal gaming.
- Asset Attachment Challenges:
The defence argues that the Enforcement Directorate’s decision to attach assets is part of a larger strategy to harass and intimidate the accused. The defence argues that the assets were properly acquired, and any association with the betting app does not necessarily constitute illicit activity. They contend that the attachment of assets contradicts fundamental legal principles, particularly the presumption of innocence.
- Political Motivation for Allegations:
In response to allegations of corruption against Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel, the defence denies any political reasons for the charges. They claim that the claims are false and are part of a political attempt to destabilize the ruling government before of elections.
- Legal Aspects of Online Betting:
The defence may also argue that online betting in India operates in a legal gray area, with unclear rules and regulations governing online gaming companies. They may question the applicability of legislation in circumstances involving internet platforms and their global activities.
Investigation:
Enforcement Directorate
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) filed a case in this matter in 2022, accusing betting promoters Saurabh Chandrakar, Ravi Uppal, Shubham Soni, and Atul Agarwal. In its inquiry, the ED claimed that the promoters of the Mahadev Book app encouraged online betting through multiple platforms employing panel operators/branch managers, keeping roughly 70-80% of the criminal revenues and distributing the remainder to the panel operators/branch managers. ED also claimed that a significant portion of Mahadev Book’s earnings were spent on its promotion, and that the promoters organized grand parties in Dubai during the book’s anniversaries in September 2021 and September 2022, to which Bollywood actors, singers, and comedians were invited, and payments were made to them using the illicit funds obtained from betting.
On March 4, 2024, EOW filed a first information report (FIR) naming 19 individuals and attached assets totaling ₹2,296 crores in the Mahadev App case. The assets included ₹19.36 crores in cash and ₹16.68 crores in jewels. On March 4, 2024, EOD listed former Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel as an accused in a case including charges of cheating, criminal conspiracy, breach of trust, and forgery under relevant provisions of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and the Prevention of Corruption Act. The case against Baghel was filed after the ED sent two references to the state police — on January 8 and 30 of that year — based on its findings that pointed to the involvement of top-level state government officers in facilitating Mahadev’s unlawful operations in exchange for “protection money”.
So far, ED has detained 11 people in connection with the case, while EOW has arrested 14. The arrestees include constables and assistant sub-inspectors (ASIs). “This is simply a political vengeance by the BJP government. We are all aware of how the Union Government misuses these central agencies,” said RP Singh, the Congress’ senior spokesperson.
CBI
In August 2024, the Chhattisgarh government referred the case to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) for further investigation. The CBI took over the probe from the Chhattisgarh Economic Offences Wing (EOW), which filed a first information report (FIR) on March 4, 2024. The FIR named 19 persons and attached assets worth ₹2,296 crore in the Mahadev App case. As of February 2025, the inquiry is still proceeding under the CBI. The investigation continues, with officials working on determining the entire scope of the illicit activity and the involvement of numerous persons.
Interim Measures:
The ED has provisionally attached assets worth ₹41 crore and conducted raids totalling ₹417 crore. These actions are intended to prevent the accused from dissipating unlawful gains throughout the inquiry. And also banned the betting app.
Conclusion:
The Mahadev Betting App case highlights weaknesses in Indian legal architecture in regulating online gambling and addressing related financial crimes. Multinational criminal networks and extradition issues hinder justice efforts. The case underscores the need for stronger legislative measures, improved cross-border collaboration, and expanded digital surveillance. It also warns about the potential for online betting and financial crimes to contribute to organized crime.
Bibliography:
